Cities & States With the Biggest Female Wage Gap

This story may be republished or used in derivative works under the Creative Commons CC BY-NC 4.0 DEED license. Attribution is required.

3/1/2024

March is Women’s History Month. To honor the occasion, researchers at TruckInfo.net decided to analyze the impact women have had on the labor force, how they are represented across various occupations, the wage gap, and how it’s changed over time.

Using data from the US Census Bureau and Department of Labor, they found the following trends.

1. The labor force continues to become more female

In 1948, women only accounted for 28% of the labor force. While female representation rapidly increased until the early 90s, growth has slowed considerably – from 45% in 1990 to just under 47% in 2022.

Related: Protect your business with commercial truck insurance

2. While women make up just under half of the labor force, many occupations are highly segregated

Women have entered the workforce in mass – dominating certain occupations though avoiding others. While women make up more than 97% of preschool and kindergarten teachers, they only represent 1.6% of automotive technicians and mechanics.

Female-dominated occupations

Occupation Male Employment Female Employment % Female
Preschool and kindergarten teachers 13,288 505,451 97.4%
Childcare workers 18,982 372,968 95.2%
Executive secretaries and executive administrative assistants 13,612 225,317 94.3%
Dental assistants 13,126 178,388 93.1%
Secretaries and administrative assistants, except legal, medical, and executive 104,869 1,400,334 93.0%
Medical assistants 41,162 424,608 91.2%
Medical records specialists 14,853 150,408 91.0%
Veterinary technologists and technicians 12,632 107,502 89.5%
Receptionists and information clerks 80,272 670,567 89.3%
Hairdressers, hairstylists, and cosmetologists 42,836 346,777 89.0%

Only occupations with at least 10k male employees and 10k female employees included in analysis

Male-dominated occupations

Occupation Male Employment Female Employment % Female
Automotive service technicians and mechanics 711,420 11,515 1.6%
Carpenters 869,538 17,109 1.9%
Electricians 808,472 16,117 2.0%
Construction laborers 1,212,160 43,451 3.5%
First-line supervisors of construction trades and extraction workers 565,155 22,280 3.8%
Maintenance and repair workers, general 622,312 25,704 4.0%
Industrial and refractory machinery mechanics 291,173 12,483 4.1%
Machinists 301,770 13,317 4.2%
Firefighters 306,960 16,193 5.0%
Welding, soldering, and brazing workers 457,887 25,422 5.3%

Only occupations with at least 10k male employees and 10k female employees included in analysis

Related: Compare trucking software and dispatch software providers

3. The wage gap exists across the country – but not in every occupation

Although the wage gap has become politically charged, there’s no denying it exists. Some female academics have pointed out that since most wage gap analyses don’t account for things like seniority or hours worked, it doesn’t mean there is significant gender discrimination. Still, others counter that those factors are examples of differential treatment or societal expectations.

Regardless of the cause, women that work full-time make $0.82 for every $1 men that work full-time make. Interestingly, occupations that skew heavily male actually pay women better than occupations that skew heavily female (though the wage gap still persists).

Female pay in female-dominated occupations

Occupation Male Median Income Female Median Income Female/Male Median Income Ratio
Preschool and kindergarten teachers $38,933 $34,472 $0.89
Childcare workers $36,302 $26,820 $0.74
Executive secretaries and executive administrative assistants $63,168 $66,750 $1.06
Dental assistants $46,858 $37,080 $0.79
Secretaries and administrative assistants, except legal, medical, and executive $50,397 $43,062 $0.85
Medical assistants $40,256 $36,930 $0.92
Medical records specialists $62,677 $47,679 $0.76
Veterinary technologists and technicians $41,083 $36,111 $0.88
Receptionists and information clerks $39,448 $34,147 $0.87
Hairdressers, hairstylists, and cosmetologists $42,387 $34,470 $0.81

Only occupations with at least 10k male employees and 10k female employees included in analysis

Female executives assistants make $1.06 for every dollar a male assistant makes.

Female pay in male-dominated occupations

Occupation Male Median Income Female Median Income Female/Male Income Ratio
Automotive service technicians and mechanics $46,875 $43,097 $0.92
Carpenters $46,567 $32,484 $0.70
Electricians $60,671 $50,310 $0.83
Construction laborers $41,197 $35,888 $0.87
First-line supervisors of construction trades and extraction workers $66,251 $52,112 $0.79
Maintenance and repair workers, general $53,041 $40,931 $0.77
Industrial and refractory machinery mechanics $62,445 $51,370 $0.82
Machinists $54,838 $36,639 $0.67
Firefighters $78,369 $70,174 $0.90
Welding, soldering, and brazing workers $49,245 $40,787 $0.83

Only occupations with at least 10k male employees and 10k female employees included in analysis

Wage gap by state

At the state level, Vermont has the smallest wage gap while Utah has the largest.

Large cities with the largest wage gap

City Male Median Income Female Median Income Female/Male Income Ratio
Seattle, Washington $88,667 $59,576 $0.67
El Paso, Texas $38,033 $26,608 $0.70
San Jose, California $72,474 $50,833 $0.70
Aurora, Colorado $50,742 $35,735 $0.70
San Diego, California $60,537 $44,008 $0.73
Wichita, Kansas $43,315 $31,843 $0.74
Bakersfield, California $42,030 $30,993 $0.74
Virginia Beach, Virginia $52,899 $39,070 $0.74
Colorado Springs, Colorado $50,046 $37,058 $0.74
Omaha, Nebraska $48,234 $36,015 $0.75

Large cities with the smallest wage gap

City Male Median Income Female Median Income Female/Male Income Ratio
Los Angeles, California $42,107 $38,099 $0.90
Oakland, California $60,113 $53,914 $0.90
Fresno, California $39,102 $34,982 $0.89
Detroit, Michigan $31,443 $27,735 $0.88
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania $43,179 $37,976 $0.88
Cleveland, Ohio $34,354 $30,067 $0.88
Washington, District of Columbia $80,852 $70,426 $0.87
Milwaukee, Wisconsin $39,972 $34,751 $0.87
Portland, Oregon $52,804 $45,523 $0.86
Long Beach, California $48,956 $41,962 $0.86

4. While the wage gap persists, female wages have grown faster than men’s wages since 2010

In Vermont, female wages have grown 151% faster than male wages since 2010. While an outlier, the majority of states have seen female wages grow 120%+ faster than male wages over the same period.

Related: See the best ELDs for owner operators

Full Data

Methodology & Data Sources

Income and employment data was sourced from the US Census Bureau. The top and bottom 10 lists for female occupations filtered out occupations with fewer than 10,000 individuals for males and females. Data on the labor force composition over time was sourced from the Department of Labor.

Large cities were defined as cities with a population over 350,000; mid-size cities as populations from 150,000-349,999; and small cities as populations under 150,000.

About the Author
Kyle Fretwell of TruckInfo.net
Kyle Fretwell has worked as a researcher and data journalist for over a decade. His work has appeared in publications such as Bloomberg, Fox Business, MSN, USA Today, CNBC, and the Houston Chronicle.

He now manages TruckInfo.net's content team and is a regular fixture at the Mid-America Trucking Show in Louisville.

Trending Guides

Blue Semi-trucks in parking lot

Paid CDL Training Programs

Bobtail Semi Truck

Bobtail Insurance Companies

A semi truck being loaded with cargo

Cargo Insurance Companies